http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d809ccdb9&template=with-video&confirm=trueThe inevitable news of Brett Favre's trade to the New York Jets came tonight. As an avid football fan, I have followed the drama that was his un-retirement with a lot of consideration. The Happy ending: Brett Favre, one of the best that's ever played--maybe THE best--bids a tearful farewell and rides off into the sunset. Yeah, right. Knowing him as only an avid football fan who knows only what the press publishes about him, it seemed a little too easy. 2nd place MVP last season, one of the best of his career and 1 busted play away from the Big Game...and he retires? Weird.
I'm not shocked that he didn't really want to retire, and I'm not shocked that he's back. Sports history is replete with people reconsidering retirement. Has it ever gone well? Generally no, but there is no doubt that the man has a passion for the game...that's why we all fell in love with him. He is the icon of every armchair quarterback who lives for football but could never play the game for real. He could not give up playing football anymore that we could give up watching it. And if you're Brett Favre, could you sit around Sundays
watching football knowing that you should be
playing it? No way.
Pure speculation to follow here, but I think Favre wanted out of Green Bay. It's the reason he retired instead of following up his amazing season, and the reason for all the previous un-retirement false starts, and the reason why no matter what else has been offered on his way back to the Packers stadium, he never seemed set to actually return to the Packers (other than to engage in talks in person).
OK, so he's back and not going to play for the Packers. I could accept that. The rumor was he wanted to play for the Vikings. I could even root for that; they are an up-and-coming team with a dynamic running game and the need for a stable QB. But the JETS? C'mon. They were 4-12 last year; a mark that would normally have buried them in the AFC East but for the woeful Dolphins and ties them for 2nd-to-last place in the Conference (tied 3rd-to-last in the NFL). They were below most other teams in almost every important stat and their offseason was arguably uneventful (until now), highlighted by a QB fight between two mediocre choices. Favre gives them a QB identity now, but I can't shake the image of a little boy bailing the Titanic with a bowl. This is not a team with a buzz coming into pre-season (again until now).
So Favre gets to play, but being the competitor he is, I can't imagine that he's going to end this next season satisfied as he's staring at the hind end of the Patriots, the Bills, and maybe even the Dolphins (depending on how fast Parcells can work his magic). Speaking of teams that need a solid QB....
In other words, WTF is he thinking? Playing football...ANY football is better than being happily retired? Yeah, that probably is what he's thinking. Maybe if you're him and you have that itch, you've got a point. Personally I don't care about his "legacy"; he owns most of the QB records (expect his Interception record to grow with the Jets) and he'll never accomplish with the Jets what he accomplished with the Packers, leading him to still generally be thought of as a Packer (like Emmitt Smith is a Cowboy even though he went to the Cardinals for a few years at the end). He's just padding those stats and scratching that itch until the day comes when they have to carry him off on his shield. I can respect that. And while there's a poison pill in the contract that prevents the Jets from trading Favre to the Vikings, the details are sketchy enough that I wonder if that applies beyong the 2008 season? Maybe after 1 unsatisfying season he can go where ever he wants.
And I was just hearing that there's still a chance that Brett could say "no" to the deal (as of this writing he hasn't officially commented on accepting it) and retire again. A bumpy ride to the sunset, but still more satisfying than seeing him play for that other team from New Jersey....
Bleck. Oh well, football is coming and I have HBO Hard Knocks with the Cowboys to keep me warm.
Happy Season everyone. May the Football Fairy bless your team to be the lucky one that the Cowboys crush on their way to their 6th Superbowl ring....