Let me start with what I like about the album. I like that Madonna is still taking risks this far into her career when she doesn't necessarily need to and that once again she is offering her audience something completely different then she has done before. That said, I wish she would have some how found a way to stay true to herself a little bit more in the process.
She has stated on several occasions that this time around she was not the only diva in the studio. Unfortunately this comes through in the music. As a devoted Madonna fan, I feel that her personal touch is what is missing to make this album a Madonna classic. If I wanted to listen to Timberlake or Timbaland then I would buy their albums. But I don't. On a few tracks it feels as if Timberlakes influence is over shadowing Madonna. Even in the lyrics there seems to be something a little strange and phony going on. Almost as if Madonna was trying to sound cool and appeal to a younger crowd rather then writing lyrics that came from her heart. (See my bootie get down like that/ if someone wants to pimp your style)
I think that timing is an issue as well. This album came out after we have been saturated with Timbaland and Tiberlake for a solid 3 year span. I think that the collaborations with Pharell are by far the better tracks on the album. He was able to follow Madonna's groove and bring something new to the plate without compromising the Madonna sound and attitude that we know and love. All and all it is a good Madonna album but not one of her best.
Here are my track by tack reviews going from my favorite to my least favorite track:
1- CANDYSHOP: this is urban Madonna at her most delicious! In my opinion this should have been the first single. The lyrics are fun and clever and I can't help but dance every time I hear it. I love it!
2- SPANISH LESSON: I know that this one is not very popular with both fans and critics but I think that it's so much fun. Again the beats make me want to jump up and dance and I think that this would be a great song to perform live.
3- BEAT GOES ON: I love the disco feel to this track it reminds me of Snoop Dog's ''Sexual Eruption'' and Kanye's rhymes sound awesome with Madonna.
4- SHE'S NOT ME: This is the Madonna that we love, putting that wannabe in her place! It has an engaging groove and her vocals sound great!
5- INCREDIBLE: I love the lyrics and Madonna's vulnerable vocals but I think that it would work better as a ballad. The beats are a little annoying in the first half of the song but still one of my favorites.
6- MILES AWAY: This is the best of the Timbaland tracks. This one sounds like it comes from Madonna's heart but once again I think it would work better as an acoustic ballad.
7- GIVE IT TO ME: Another fun track on the album. This one captures Madonna's essence as a grown woman not wanting to slow down. (I just wish she wouldn't say ''undress me'' she never said cheap sounding lyrics like that before so why start now?)
8- HEARTBEAT: This one sounds more like classic Madonna but I find that her songs about dancing are getting a little redundant.
9- 4 MINUTES: One of my least favorites I'm still trying to figure out why it was the first single. Madonna next to Justin just looks silly.
10- VOICES: A bit of a sleeper but I do like the lyrics and the melody.
11- THE DEVIL WOULDN'T RECOGNISE YOU: This is just not Madonna's style and I can't get into it. Her vocals are weak on this one.
12- DANCE 2 NIGHT: Yet another song about dancing in a club! It should have been on Justin's next album.