I have always been a fan of really well thought and put together mixtapes, and I love making them, especially now that I have really put in the time to properly digitize MOST of my CD collection, which leaves me a lot more time to focus on making good selection of pieces to use and on the flow of the mix. I'll post mixtapes on here as I make them, and go into detail on each selection as it is deemed appropriate.
I will try to include the song as possible, usually through Youtube videos. I would say that most songs I include will not be singles so there will not often be an official video for them. Luckily there are a lot of fan videos of a LOT of songs out there, so at least an example of a song can be found, despite the content of the video. In other cases, the only example available may be a live video, in which many cases the sound quality may be greatly compromised.
THE "UNREQUITED LOVE" MIXTAPE
This mix will focus on the lyrical content of songs that deal with the more complicated nature of relationships and love, as opposed to more simplistic "heart break" songs. Not all examples in this list are strictly about love of the "
unrequited" kind, but they do deal with issues about which what we deeply want cannot be had, and why (even if the "why" sometimes cannot be explained in words). Sometimes love is one-sided, or instead of carried through simply with base emotions and feelings it over-intellectualized to the point that one's inner feelings just can't hold up to our ideals or what it is that we think we "want". That is what these songs deal with.
1. TEGAN & SARA "call it off" from The Con
This song is bittersweet in its dual feelings of relief and regret. It's one of those instances in which someone has made a decision to end something before it was able to truly form into anything more…and perhaps that decision leads to heart-break, but maybe it was in fact for the best. It's one of those "we'll never know situations. The first lines of the chorus, though, are especially telling:
"Maybe I would have been something you'd be good at
Maybe you would have been something I'd be good at
But now we'll never know"
It's a good abstraction of love and affection into a skill, as if the challenge of being with and keeping another person happy is something that someone may or may not be able to do.
2. A PERFECT CIRCLE "orestes" (Billy Howerdel solo acoustic demo)
This song may not be a perfect fit for this playlist, as it is most likely based on the greek mythological character of
Orestes, but with its highly symbolic nature, it can be interpreted in several ways.
I would interpret the lyrics as being about a relationship in which one person is feeding off of the other in very negative ways, as in a symbiotic way. It feels like Billy Howerdel's lyrics confess a feeling of being parasitic to his lover, and despite the strong love between them both, it has to stop because in the end his latching on will only serve to end in tragedy:
"Gotta cut away, clear away
Slip away and sever this
Umbilical residue,
Keeping me from killing you
And from pulling you down with me here,
I can almost hear you scream"
This demo version of the song, simply played with an acoustic guitar and sung by Howerdel instead of Maynard James Keenan has a much more intimate, vulnerable feel to it then the more epic studio sound that A Perfect Circle has, and adds to this feeling even more.
[I am not sure where or if this track is available on any official releases…it was quite popular among P2P networks years ago. It's worth track down for sure though. To hear more of Howerdel's great vocals, you should also check out his new band
Ashes Divide,
Album version for reference
3. ONELINEDRAWING "superhero" from The Volunteers
This song, to me, is about how when we first meet someone and fall in love, we are so overcome with those feelings that we put blindly put them up on a pedestal and create a dream image of what they are and how amazing they are:
"When you make someone into a superhero
know that they will fly
and they will see right through you
they will burn so bright
that they will make you blind
yeah they will make you blind"
Unfortunately these images will often be tarnished by the harsh reality of how people really are. It's not to say that the person isn't truly good or loving or caring…but that dream image that was created will be gone when the realization that it never existed comes to fruition, and we find ourselves longing for that person that we thought we had found. Ultimately, the song conjures thoughts of hope that this is something that can be overcome, although we're still left with feelings of incompleteness.
4. AGAINST ME "pints of guinness make you strong" from Reinventing Axl Rose
This is a touching song about how love can be everlasting, and sometimes because of it, can be quite painful. It tell the story of Evelyn and how she lost her husband James to alcoholism 37 years ago and the pain caused by it made her never have the heart to be able love anyone else again.
"if we're never together if I'm never back again well i swear to god that i'll love you forever. Evelyn I'm not coming home tonight. in all the years that went by she said she'd always love him, and from the day that he died she never loved again."
The references to "drinking Irish" and Guinness marks remembrance and honor of the dead, as well as never being able to forget or let go of someone, no matter the passage of time.
5. APOPTYGMA BERZERK "until the end of the world (acoustic version)" from In This Together single
This song is really the definition of unreiquited love…it speaks about a powerful love that fate just will not allow to happen:
"All the weights that keep me down
seem heavier than before
fate hits me in my face
though you feel nothing"
The narrator appears compulsively desperate to make his pleas heard but they fall on deaf ears. Perhaps the line "I cry out loud but you hear nothing" is actually representative of an internal cry because for some reason he can't express himself. Nonetheless, He's willing to wait "until the end of the world" for her
This acoustic version of the song, released as a B-side on the single for the song "In This together" resonates with much more heartache and vulnerability than the original version from the Harmonizer record, which is very fast paced and has a hugely anthemic electronic pop quality to it.
Album version for reference
6. OSKER "disconnect, disconnect" from Idle Will Kill
For me, this song fits in with the same themes represented in Onelinedrawing's "Superhero," but this time from the perspective of the person who has been imaginarily built up and is now angry and bitter about his inability to live up to expectations. This section from the second verse sums it all up:
"I couldn't carry a Goddamn thing,
But you, but you gave it anyway.
Half-flattered you believed in me,
Half-sorry you made a mistake."
From the very first line in the song, "Every time I hear your name, It bears an uncanny resemblance to defeat," it describes the inadequacies felt from any simple reference to where he went wrong. The chorus and title refer to the overwhelming desire to disassociate himself with any and all memories of the incident and of her, because it reminds him of his own failure.
Unfortunately, there are no videos of this song, and almost no videos available of Osker AT ALL, but I urge you check out the whole album, Idle Will Kill. It's one of the most personal and painful "punk" related albums I've ever heard, and deals with many issues of being a young adult, such as trying to fit into one's own skin, dealing with not being able to live up to people's expectations, and realizing when one hasn't or maybe even isn't going to achieve the dreams that they have always had.
7. DUSTIN KENSRUE "I knew you before" from Please Come Home
Dustin is the lead singer from
THRICE, and this comes from his first solo album, which has a very Johnny Cash-esque country bar band sound. This song sounds to me like the judgmental sermon of someone telling the story to an ex-lover about her own fall from grace into the excesses of lust and promiscuity in order to try and fit in.
On one hand it reads like a cautionary tale about the pitfalls of giving into the temptations strewn about by the media of how to be accepted
"The magazines and media supplied you with their plastic protocol
And maybe music television really is the devil after all"
And as a consequence the lines of love and lust become blurred because of the necessity to feel love and comfort from others:
"And all you want is to hear the words:
"Dear baby I love you"
So you hike your skirt higher still
'Till there eyes are all on you"
On the other hand, as the song concludes it starts to bear the naivety of an ex-loved or someone who has always cradled a desperate adoration to be able to "save" that person:
"And all I can say is I knew you before
You were beautiful back then
You could be beautiful again"
8. DEPECHE MODE "world full of nothing" from Black Celebration"
This song talks about a young couple's first time having sex and the magnitude it has. A first time, a young experience like a high school romance isn't necessarily about love, because people don't really have the capacity or the life experience to truly be able to emotionally connect in a way like that. BUT, when you're young, you'll take what you can get, because you're idealistic and you think that love and companionship is something you need, something to fight for.
"She's lonely
And he says
It's for her only
That he lusts
She doesn't trust him
Nothing is true
But he will do"
[Thematically similar, check out this great live version of TEGAN & SARA's
Nineteen, which I didn't include in the list because I thought "cut you off" was more relevant]
9. BOYS NIGHT OUT "let me be your swear word" from S/T
This is an interesting reflection on a relationship in which two people are not really fit for each other, so they get drunk and have sex, and continuing an ongoing threesome between themselves and the bottle of liquor. It goes into detail about the physicality of the relationship and the role of the alcohol, but then
"We wake up unsteady, because that's what we do.
There's no way I'm good for you.
You stand up and hurry me out of your room.
I got it, I'm leaving!"
10. DESCENDENTS "I'm the one" from Everything Sucks
Here's another falls distinctly into the textbook definition of "unrequited love" and also tells a story that I am sure a lot of people are familiar with – the guy that falls head over heels for a girl, and will do absolutely anything for her, but ultimately ends up in the position of her "
gay friend,"
"i'm the one who wants you more than anything
you don't feel the same way you made it clear to me
but i'll stand my ground and maybe
you'll hear what i've been sayin"
WHICH, unfortunately is pretty pathetic. So he stands by and idly watches her go through bad relationship after bad relationship and listens to her complain about them, hoping that she'll come around and reciprocate his affection
"'m the one
i've been here for you all along
i'm the one
who's shoulder you've been cryin on
nice guys finish last
no one knows as good as me
we're just good friends
and you come to me for sympathy
you tell me that i'm not your type
still you call me late at night
everytime he picks a fight"
11. GREG GRAFFIN "maybe she will" from American Lesion
This is from Greg Graffin of Bad Religion's first solo record, which saw him taking a much more personal approach to his music. In this, Graffin ponders an ex-lover and through turmoil and nightmares he retains a glimmer of hope that she will simply change her mind and return to him
"In cold and darkest weather, the times we had together
Come to me and I smile to sleep
The clouds dissapate and I soon re-awake
To such a living tragedy
I'm resolved to pondering
Maybe she will"
It is a song of desperation, constantly refraining "maybe" this and "maybe" that, simply leaving things up to fate instead of taking action himself. It kind of takes the thought of endearing love for a person to levels of self-torture, to simply think about and let the past constantly resonate without attempting to create a new future. Instead of painting a picture of anger or any real passion, it's a testimony to a stagnant existence of futile yearning but never receiving.
12. HUMAN LEAGUE "louise" from Hysteria
"Louise" is similar thematically to "maybe she will," but less tragic and more melancholic. It tells the story of a couple that broke things off long ago, yet the feelings still linger for both.
"Hello, Louise,
Remember me?
Now should we part
Or stay awhile?
As if we were still lovers"
They share a chance meeting after having not each other for a while, and though they both see that their feelings for each other are still there, they realize that what they had before will never be the same again, because they have both changed.
13. BECK "think I'm in love" from The Information
To me, this song is about someone who is in a relationship, but has a deathly fear, not necessarily of commitment, but from actually allowing himself to fall in love and be happy. Naturally, the chorus
"I think I'm in love
But it makes me kinda nervous to say so"
Makes a pretty clear statement about his wishy washy nature and anxiety, but this section
"Take a little picture in a photobooth
Keep it in a locket and I think of you
Both of our pictures, face to face
Take off your necklace and throw it away"
Really helps solidify the idea that being together with someone is just downright terrifying, despite the affections that she attempts to show to him
13. CURSIVE "the game of who needs who the worst" from Domestica
This comes from Cursive's excellent "Domestica" record, which is a concept album detailing a troubling relationship and its apparent collapse. This song alludes to adultery
"A little bit closer
Your lipstick is smudged, dear
Here, let me wipe that smirk off "
And its use within this twisted relationship as a sort of chess play, as if the relationship were some sort of sick game
"Relations, in direct competition
Domination
The players, disguised as the lovers
The best friend
A game of who needs who the worst"
The game plays out by testing one's love by tearing them down psychologically and emotionally. It goes back and forth, back and forth until someone either gives up or gives in. The question is: if it's "true love" do we try to work these things out and suffer through it, or do we chalk it up as finally over once we get to these harrowing points?
14. LIZ PHAIR "fuck and run" from Exit To Guyville
This is a sad story from someone who wishes they could find love and be in a relationship, something constant, with all the bells and whistles, but instead just continues to put herself into situations in which she has meaningless sex that would not and will not lead to anything else. And no matter how many times in the song she says
"I didn't think this would happen again"
And longs for something more, she sets herself up for failure. Deep inside she know her own self-fulfilling prophecy
"And I can feel it in my bones
I'm gonna spend another year alone
It's fuck and run, fuck and run
Even when I was seventeen
Fuck and run, fuck and run
Even when I was twelve"
Whew
….and now
FREE (or cheap) GOOD MUSIC!
I was on Wikipedia this weekend gathering information to update my "albums to buy" list and discovered that the amazing mash-up DJ
GIRL TALK released a new album on June 19th, and following in the footsteps of Radiohead, is offering it to fans at "choose your own price," which means the record could be free if one chooses. There are different benefits associated with paying different prices, like better compression ratios, and getting the physical version of the album when it drops in September. I paid $5.00 because it gave me the option of getting it as a continuous mix on a single track…which is really the way something like this should be heard.
The album is called FEED THE ANIMALS

And like his last album, features HUNDREDS of bits of popular songs mixed together, cut to fuck, and mashed up into a brilliant new animal. This guy makes me truly enjoy music I would normally hate. Make sure to check it out.
Click Here to get FEED THE ANIMALS! And while we're talking about free music, be sure to check out Nine Inch Nails newest full length album, THE SLIP, which he offered to fans COMPLETELY FOR FREE, no questions asked!
Click Here to get THE SLIP! 'Till next time…
-Andrew