After the atrocity on the baseball diamond last night, I breathed a sigh of relief. This sad, sad season full of expectations had mercifully come to an end (wording courtesy of Abby The Skinny). And although the playoffs will be fun, I can't help but wonder about the Tigers' future and what is now their offseason as of 24 hours ago.
As you can tell from my notes, I talk quite a bit about the Tigs, both online and with Mr. Happy and Papa Worm. That is one of the things I enjoy most about baseball (and sports in general), being able to question decisions and hypothesize even though your solutions have no impact whatsoever on the outcome. It's kind of like politics, only a lot less depressing.
Obviously it is very easy to formulate an opinion about the Tigers and what they should do. It may come as a surprise, but I'm not a crazily obsessed fan. I don't quote stats like OPS or defensive ratings and I'm not all that familiar with pending free agents (see The Detroit Tigers Weblog for reader comments related to that, but the blog itself is a great resource for the overzealous or casual fan). That being said, when were statistics and new acquisitions a guarantee for success? So, if you have a passion for the game, you're just as reliable as a source of information as 'Testes' Orestes Destrade.
Okay, who am I kidding, that guy doesn't know jack...but does look good in turquoise.
Continuing on, this note was written with me basically thinking out loud. Obviously I was completely wrong on my prediction for this year and I doubt any of these changes will really happen. Still, it's fun to live in a fantasy land where you rule the Tigers. Feel free to join the confabulation.
----------
Step 1) Fire Jim Leyland, Hire Matt Walbeck
This might seem a bit drastic considering Leyland led us to the World Series only a couple seasons ago and we all wrote him in for governor. However, I'm afraid he's lost this team. Clearly they were not ready coming out of spring training and he had no clue what he had in the dugout. He is not to blame for Renteria, Sheffield, Willis, Robertson...and so many others...having off years. He is to blame for the following:
- Poor pitching decisions, be it leaving Verlander out there for 120 pitches each outing or ever giving the ball to Gary Glover. His moves were very Alan Trammell-esque and seemed to be based a lot on matchups, not his superior "gut". It wouldn't kill ya to leave Seay out there to face right handers.
- Badly handling the young players, which is the main reason why I think we should look to Walbeck. How can you give consistent playing time to a guy who isn't performing (Sheffield), then demote and berate players like Larish, Cleven, and Thomas when they do well? It doesn't make a lot of sense to me and I question how that is acting like a "players' manager". Quite giving time to the contracts and play the real players.
- Acting like a buffoon and poorly representing the Tigers. From ripping on the pitching staff late in the year to that nutso incident in Texas with the umpires. What does that say? I know it's been a frustrating year and the players have just as much of a right to want to go crazy too. But they didn't. Sure there was the brawl, but that was on Sheff. And to argue balls and strikes when the closer you insisted on leaving in can't get an out to save his life, that's on you and not the umpires missing a strike on the first batter of a long inning.
As for a replacement, I think we dropped the ball on letting Bruce Fields leave the organization a few years ago and I hope we don't do it with Walbeck. He now has major league managing experience in addition to having success at several levels within our organization. As he moved up the ranks, so did many of our top prospects. I liked the piece they did on him during the Rangers series which allowed Walbeck to explain how proud he was of his ex-players. That...is being a class act. Maybe Leyland can take a lesson.
In the interim, keep an eye on ex-Whitecaps pitching coach A.J. Sager. He is at Toledo now and I believe was with Walbeck for a time. We need some fresh blood and I like going from within the organization. Let's just hope the hiring process goes more smoothly than the firing process of Jeff Jones and Chuck Hernandez.
Step 2) Make Inge your full-time third baseman.
Yeah yeah, this already happened, but I came up with the theory first (and so did a lot of other Tigers fans). It really makes you wonder why it took so long to come to this conclusion. I disagree with fans who believe that if you play a certain position (except DH), you have to hit for a certain average. Inge will save enough runs to make up for his lack of production at the plate, just as he always has.
Step 3) Platoon Dusty Ryan and James Skelton.
You probably aren't familiar with the latter, but he's a skinny catcher who was down at Lakeland this year and later at Erie. I think they would make a great tandem only because they are so different. I'm not a stats guy (as mentioned), but their on-base plus slugging is essentially equal from the minors this year. However, Skelton is a lefty swinger and walks a decent amount. Ryan is a lot bigger and hits with more pop. I think they would be an interesting every day addition to the lineup and we could even throw Skelton in at the top of the order to bat Grandy lower.
Step 4) Build this rotation.
1: Verlander
2: Galarraga
3: Garcia
4: Bonderman
5: Miner
Bondo is the biggest question mark, in my opinion. If he poops out, you still have options in the minors or *gasp* Robertson. I think Nate is much better served in the bullpen with his mentality and I hope he gains some of that fire once again when he left many runners on base. Maybe if he brought back Gum Time...
Step 5) Gut the bullpen.
Easy to write, hard to fix. I would bring back Seay, Zumaya, and Frodney. I expect nothing out of the last two, but hey, at least they showed us something in 2006 (yes, I realize I'm holding them to a different standard than Leyland). How in the world you piece the thing back together is beyond me. See, it would be helpful if I had some scouts right now. And if you want to get really distraught, look at how Byrdak and Grilli did this year for the Astros and Rockies. Oh, Awesome Fossum you were a sad replacement...
Step 6) D-Train, the outfielder.
Hey, it worked for the Cardinals with Rick Ankiel. And if you don't do that, at least stop messing with the guy's mechanics he's used since he was 10.
Step 7) Bring back Edgar.
As much as I would like to see an amazing defense on the left side of the infield, I'm still a little leery of leaving Santiago out there for a full season. I know he's Mr. Happy's boy and he did have a power surge late. Still, for what we gave up for Renteria, I think we have to see if he can make that trade look a little less lopsided. Give him another year at a huge discount. He did have a solid second half and just as many errors as a supposedly great defender like Orlando Cabrera.
Step 8) Cut Sheffield early.
Again, tied down to a bad trade and a big contract, we have to give him another look. If he sucks early on, prevent him from impeding the development of our young guys. Give his at-bats away just like he does, only this time maybe someone else will do something with them.
Step 9) Build from within.
I'm done with spending a ton of money. If we are going to be a perennial threat, we have to buy into a philosophy like the Twins. They draft and bring up only the players that fit their system. Minnesota wins year in and year out, no matter who is on their roster. That way, you'll never have to suffer reading through such a long note ever again.
----------
Anyhow, that's a few ideas. Will any of them happen? Doubtful (hey, Inge might be our SS by 2009 knowing Leyland). But is it fun to speculate? Yes, and even better to hope.
Fearing he's going to wear a knee brace (Brian Cardinal style) when he runs (because he's so old),
Worm.