(basically, an friend of mine recently posted an comment on Facebook stating she wanted to reduce her carbon foot print.
so being the nice vegan I am, i replied saying she should drive less and go vegan.
she replied with the general argument you can't be vegan and healthy...going as far as saying vegans look sickly.
so i'm composing a thorough response. my only concern is that i don't want to come across as an asshole vegan looking to pick a fight. as i said, we were never very close friends. so i'm wondering if i should just drop it and let her continue to think her false info is correct. but the righteous vegan in me is making me feel like i should post it. I want other's opinions and think it's a well enough written response that others might want to use it.) Please respond with any and all comments, I'd like all perspectives.....
XXX is really starting to worry about her carbon footprint this year. ....
Bernard Jones at 10:18am March 16....
Driving less and eating less animal products (veganism) will have the greatest impact to reducing your cfp. :)
http://www.ecostreet.com/blog/sustainable-lifestyle/2007/09/11/7-big-ways-to-reduce-your-carbon-footprint/....
.. ..
XXX at 12:21pm March 16....
Yeah, it's just really really hard to be vegan and be healthy. You have to do it so carefully and so well, and I'm not into that-I have a hard enough time staying healthy. And I don't drive much-I live in ....England.....
Bernard Jones at 10:03am March 17....
It's not THAT hard to be vegan and healthy, especially with all the great food options available today. Just like with everything meaningful in life; staying in shape, reducing your carbon footprint, making a positive difference in your community, etc, it takes practice and determinate...anyone can do it! :) I've been doing it for 12 years and have never been healthier. If I can eat healthy vegan in a small town in northern ..Norway.. I’m sure it can be done in ....England..... If you want to see what’s in your area, check out: http://www.happycow.net/europe/england/
Cheers!....
.. ..
XXX at 9:24am March 18....
Well, all I can say is that I've never met a vegan who really looks healthy. You're probably an exception. :) But I have seen girls' reproductive systems get messed up/delayed, and it would be really hard to give the right nutrients to a baby if I decided to have kids. I lived with vegetarians for a while and they were incredibly careful and educated about it, and it was really hard to do it right and get all of the amino acids...and most of that family now eat meat and fish again. Plus, soy products have a lot of health risks which are underplayed, particularly for women. I do try and eat meat/fish only a few times a week, rather than every day, but I'm just too health-conscious to give up such a good source of protein, vitamins, iron, omegas, etc. Anyway, I buy green energy, and use public transport, and recycle in a country where it's tough to recycle. So that's my way of helping out. We can only do our best, and that's different for each of us.....
.. ..
MY PROPOSED RESPONSE:
(not sure why I did this, I guess I was just bored and couldn’t sleep)
.. ..
My response below is not meant to convince you to become vegan, but rather to show you some other reliable sources of information that may not agree with you’re current understanding of nutrition in hopes that you and/or your veg*n friends will be healthier. And while most of what I’ve referenced is from Wikipedia, I’m not implying that it is the only or best source for generally accepted information, but rather that it was quickest to find and the info is regulated to be from a neutral perspective by the public.
.. ..
It makes me concerned to hear you’ve never met a vegan that looks healthy. You should check out photos of my friends either on FB or MS, because many of them are vegan and they all look very healthy. In fact they often look healthier than some of my meat/fish/dairy eating friends. Perhaps is a ....UK.... thing to look sickly since it’s apparently hard to even recycle there or simply a vegan stereotype?
http://www.recycle-more.co.uk/
It’s pretty widely known that there’s no consensus on the nutrition argument for animal vs. plant based diets, but to say that one NEEDS to consume animal based proteins/vitamins to be healthy is a blatantly false statement.
While soy does contain estrogen, it’s also a complete protein, meaning it contains ALL the essential amino acids that body can’t produce alone.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soy
And the ‘health risks’ you speak of are as of yet clinically unfounded and largely based on the popular misapprehension that estrogen and testosterone have a simple, inverse relationship in sexual hormone systems and sex-related behaviour
There are also many other great sources of protein for vegans including legumes, some grains, quinoa, and spirulina.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_protein
Actually, the ONLY vitamin a vegan can’t get from eating every day whole foods is B-12, but almost all cereals and soy/rice milks are fortified with it so it’s a non-issue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_B12
To hear that your vegetarian friends now eat meat or fish out of nutritional concerns shows they were never very educated to begin with about their real nutritional needs because a vegan diet is healthier in many ways to other omnivorous diets. The list of health benefits is nearly endless.
If you’re of the belief that animal based sources of vitamins like iron, calcium, folic acid, vitamin D, or omega-3’s are the best or only sources you might want to read more about it. Most everyday grain based foods are already fortified with these nutrients. In fact flax seeds are 6 times higher in omega’s than fish and the heavy metal contamination in certain types of fish actually make it an unhealthy choice, especially for babies.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron#Nutrition_and_dietary_sources
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calcium#Nutrition
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folic_acid#Dietary_fortification
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_d#Nutrition
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omega-3_fatty_acid#Dietary_sources
And since it’s totally unnecessary and very unnatural that people continue to drink milk after weaning, which is why so many people are lactose intolerant. Furthermore, the health risks from a diet high in dairy has significant and verified health risks, partially because of all the hormones and chemicals pumped into cows so they produce unnatural amounts of milk.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milk#Nutrition_and_health
What nutrients do you think that a baby needs that are only animal derived? Breast feeding is the only real option for infants and if a woman simply eats a healthy well balanced vegan diet, LIKE EVERYONE SHOULD, there’s no excuse why vegan babies can’t be healthy too.
http://jn.nutrition.org/cgi/content/full/134/5/1220S
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article4131103.ece
http://www.vrg.org/nutrition/pregnancy.htm
Many misconceptions about vegan babies are based on sensationalized media and from reports like the author of this article that clearly hasn’t done her homework or read half the information I just posted above.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/21/opinion/21planck.html
http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2007/05/vegan_diet_no_g.html (check out the responses towards the bottom of the page from vegans and non-vegans alike regarding the nytimes article)
.. ..
As with any new or unconventional ideas (hypothesis), there will be opposition until the knowledge becomes widespread and/or verified enough to be accepted by the general public (theory), much like Newton’s or Einstein’s ideas about gravity or relativity.
Good luck and I’m glad to hear you buy local, organic, and use green energy whenever you can like I do.