I'm prepared for the firestorm...but here's where I stand..
there's a [what i consider] great article blasting CESAR MILLAN currently on the NY TIMES website from last week's paper.
It basically covers and dissemeninates what most working, progressives in dog training have been chewing on since this guy started selling his witchcraft on the tube.
There's very little good to say him and the show aside from the fact that his show at least gets people THINKING about training their dogs.
His methods are archaic hocus pocus that he basically INVENTED...
He's SELF TRAINED in a field that offers VOLUMES of information ON HOW ANIMALS LEARN, and yet he knows NOTHING of that information...HE actually MYSTIFIES dog training rather than making it understandable.
DOG Training is a SCIENCE...the application can be artful, but there are simply rules that stand up to scientific inquiry.
It's easy to deny the existence of these rules if you don't understand or know them....make up your own rules and fool the world.....oy.
And the show says, "don't try this at home???", solid progressive, positive dog training is something EVERYONE should try at home...
I think dogs deserve better than being hurt with choke collars, kicked 'gently' in the flank or run on treadmills and stressed repeatedly until they exhibit his "quiet submission" when they haven't been given half a shot at learning WHAT TO DO, vs WHAT NOT TO DO...
I'd rather see him train unicorns...seems more appropriate...
HERE'S THE ARTICLE.
CESAR BLASTEDA slightly less biased article about him appears here on the malcolm gladwell blog.
gladwell blogLastly, i heard cesar was on charlie rose last week, and a friend describled it as " the greatest sixty minutes of television since
Jimi Hendrix fell asleep in the middle of a 1969 Dick Cavett interview"
look critically my friends the emperor wears no clothes.