So in my blog yesterday, I asked if anyone could find the "co-opted" joke from the movioe Boiler Room that was in question. The movie was released in the year 2000. I stated that I have been doing the following joke since 1994.
My brother Frank hates gays. He says, 'We should take all you gays and stick you on an island', "I said they have, we call it Manhattan."
A fan of both Rogan and I sent me the following email this morning:
Ant:
I'm actually a fan of both you and Joe Rogan - and this latest drama looks potentially like someone at the radio station is generating drama to me over a misunderstanding.
Anyway - you asked for someone to let you know where your joke is in Boiler Room. It is about half-way through. I don't know how to cut/edit movies and email them ......
I copy/pasted in the text from the scene for your convenience at the end of this message (your joke is at the bottom, but note that the whole exchange is very similar to your set - a good argument that you got ripped off - or honestly a good argument for parallel thinking based on the context of the scene and the movie)...
(Movie Text)
A table of gay men have been sitting next to the guys and are finally fed up with the noise. One of them turns around.
GAY MAN
Hey, do you guys think you could keep it down some.
SETH
Yeah, no problem.
STEVE
Why don't you guys just concentrate on your food instead of us.
RICHIE
Hey, what are you eating over there anyway? A little tube snake smothered in underwear?
The brokers go bonkers. They're laughing hysterically.
STEVE
I heard the hot dogs are real good here too. They got foot-longs. You like those right? A little tough to swallow, but they're good.
At this comment, the other two men at the table sit straight up, ready to engage Steve and Richie.
GAY MAN
Great outfits, you guys just come from a City Council meeting? Or you just trying to score with the bridge and tunnel crowd?
STEVE
You know what they should do with you guys? They should put all of you on a fucking island somewhere.
GAY MAN
Yeah, guess what?
STEVE
What?!
GAY MAN
You're on it!
Until you hear tape of Joe calling you a joke thief, I would assume that O&A are blowing a long-gone incident way out of proportion and it will be ended simply with you pointing out that you've told the joke since 1994 and giving everyone the finger. Radio drama... worse than soap opera.
Best regards,
Edward
Thanks Edward! I appreciate that. Now, here is the joke that Jim David (The comic I have been accused of stealing jokes from by Rogan):
I was standing in Manhattan, a man came up and said, "they ought to take all these homos and put them on an island." I said, "Merry Christmas, Bozo, you're on it." (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_David)
Again, I leave it up to you!