Ho ho ho, everybody!
I'm so glad to be back to my blog at The Memoirists Collective, after a month-long hiatus for NaNoWriMo and organizing The Best Memoirists Pageant Ever (and it was!)
And I don't return empty-handed, either! The lovely people at StuffitBag.com have donated a bunch of their funky laptop protectors to YOU, oh loyal readers of this blog! Stuffit Bags are colorful, generously padded to protect your precious writing equipment, yet super-light! (Perfect for holiday travel!) Ours are ideally sized for a 12"-wide laptop (but personally, I think you could fit up to a 14"-wide notebook in them). Want to get your mittens on one? Tell me so by posting a comment to that effect on this page, or send me a message via my personal MySpace page. But do it by midnight EST on December 14, 2007! I'll notify the winners via MySpace message on Monday, December 17, 2007.
And now…onto the blog at hand!
* * * * * *
Frosty: A Family Christmas
By Kim Brittingham
The holiday season is here -- a time when we naturally ask of our friends and co-workers, "So, where are you going for Thanksgiving? For Christmas? For New Year's? Will you be visiting family?"
And I always reply that, no, I will not be visiting family. I don't "do" family for the holidays.
This usually prompts a why.
"Are your parents dead?"
Well, you could say that. You see, I'm estranged from my family. Unofficially disowned.
But that's not necessarily a bad thing.
I'm always surprised when people really, truly want to know the details. For a couple of years, I tried handing out the story in a nutshell, but that never seemed to be enough.
And so, weary of repeating myself, I present the full story of my familial estrangement here and now, so that next time I'm asked, I can simply direct the inquiring party to this blog.
It all started about five or six years ago (I've lost count), at Christmas.
My parents live in Philadelphia; I live in New York. I used to visit them at Christmas. I'd usually show up on Christmas Eve and spend the night at my parents'. It was a terribly unhealthy thing.
Literally unhealthy, because my parents have pets. I don't know the situation now, but they used to have two cats and a dog, in a tiny little apartment with poor ventilation. And I'm extremely allergic to both types of pet.
Every year I'd end up dreadfully sick and miserable.
My mother used to keep a framed family photo on her sofa table, of her and my dad, my siblings and me, sitting in a row wearing blue tissue-paper crowns from a set of English Christmas crackers. I hated that picture. I looked like an overinflated pink balloon in a ski sweater. My face was puffed up from spending the night in the stuffy, animal-infested apartment, my eyelids inflated like marshmallows and nearly obscuring my eyes entirely, my cheeks and nose an angry red from the endless scraping of rough generic tissues against my face as I sneezed my guts up.
So a couple of weeks before my last "family Christmas", I was talking to my therapist about how I was dreading another holiday of bronchial agony for me, and excruciating boredom for my boyfriend at the time. Jim traveled faithfully by my side to so many family Christmases, always with a box of Kleenex at the ready.
"Well Kim, what are you going to do to take care of yourself this year?" my shrink asked.
It was an excellent question. Yes, I did need a game plan. One that not only took care of me, but took my mother's needs and feelings into consideration as well.
You see, Christmas has always been an important holiday to my mother. And I think her favorite part was seeing all three of her kids opening presents under the tree on Christmas morning. I didn't want to ruin that for her. So I came up with a compromise.
I called her up.
"Hey Mom, listen, I've got an idea for Christmas. Since the dog and cats bother me when I stay with you, I was thinking Jim and I could stay in a hotel on Christmas Eve instead, and come over on Christmas morning to open presents. It would cut down on some of the time I'm exposed to the animals. But also, we could go out to breakfast together on Christmas morning, either before or after presents. It'll be more time together, but without the pets. What do you think?"
"That might be nice," she said. "But do you think any place will be open on Christmas morning?"
I'd already done my homework. "The Ritz Diner on the Boulevard is open. We can be waited on, and you won't have to cook breakfast for anybody. And we can still go back to your apartment and open presents around the tree. What do you say? Should I call and make a reservation?"
"Sure," she agreed. "That sounds good."
Great! This was going to work out just fine.
There was something else about recent Christmases that had been disappointing me, though. I was never able to visit my grandmother on the holiday. My Aunt Linda always had my grandmother to her house on Christmas Day, and since I was always at my mother's, and since my mother wasn't speaking to my Aunt Linda, my path never crossed my grandmother's on Christmas.
Well, since I was taking my life into my own adult hands with the allergies thing, I decided to do something about my grandmother, too.
"Grandmom, I know you're going to Aunt Linda's on Christmas Day. But what are you doing Christmas Eve?"
Since I wouldn't be going to my mother's, I was free.
"Well, nowhere. I'll just be home here with your Uncle Russell. Your Aunt Linda and Uncle Mike might stop by."
"Would you mind if Jim and I came to visit you?"
"I would love it!" she said in her sweet, trembly voice. "But you know I go to bed early, kiddo. What time did you want to come?"
My grandmother's bedtime had been shockingly early since I was a little girl. In summer, it was still daylight when she turned in.
"I know, I know. Don't worry, here's my idea. We can come in the afternoon, say around 1:00. Now listen, I don't have control over what anybody else does, but I can promise you I won't stay later than 7:00. How does that sound?"
"Sounds good to me, kiddo!"
"And I don't want to make any extra work for you or Uncle Russell, so I'll bring food. You won't even have to feed us."
I called my mom and updated her on the plan.
"Oh, that sounds nice!" she said. "Daddy and Jen and I will come over Grandmom's after work. Maybe we can even get Scott and Patty to come by, too."
Jen is my sister, who still lived with my parents at the time; Scott and Patty are my brother and his girlfriend.
This was getting better and better! If my parents were going to come to my grandmother's on Christmas Eve, then I'd get to spend time with them on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day, after all.
As the days counted down to Christmas, I learned that more and more people were joining us at Grandmom's on Christmas Eve. Still mindful of keeping my visit work-free for her and my Uncle Russell, I decided to bring more food, for the extra company. And I'd bring paper plates too, and leave behind no dirty dishes.
The days leading up to Christmas were rough. I was having major back problems. I felt like the Tin Man when Dorothy first finds him rusted in place in the forest. My back was stiff and sore, and the smallest attempt to change position was agony. And in the midst of it all, I was making my parents' and siblings' Christmas presents -- from scratch.
I sew, and I'd gotten the idea in my head to make everyone a robe. But not from a store-bought pattern. Noooo. I had to be creative and draft my own patterns. I had to be a glutton for punishment. The men's robes were pretty straightforward, but for my mother and sister, I created a sort of kimono-inspired pullover that could be worn as a poolside cover-up. It took a lot of draping and pinning and slow dancing with a mannequin, plus MATH (which I hate). There was much painful stretching across a big table to smooth and cut long swaths of flannel, and bending over the sewing machine wasn't that therapeutic either.
On top of it, the night before Philadelphia, I was up 'til midnight preparing food for the gang expected at my grandmother's.
I needed a break, and badly.
I'd always wanted to stay at the Inn of The Dove. It's one of those cheesy highway love nests with mirrors on the ceiling where people go to fuck. It's in Pennsylvania, just outside the Philly city limits.
It didn't strike me as particularly romantic or arousing, either in theory or actuality, but I heard they had suites with huge four-person hot tubs in them. Right there, in the motel rooms! Right next to the king-size beds! As a water baby, I had to experience this luxury at least once in my lifetime. With the large-screen TV in perfect view from the tub, there was a real danger they might need to call in the law to drag my shriveled butt out.
It was expensive, but Jim agreed to spend Christmas Eve at the kinky Dove, so I could soak my aching back. As long as we were leaving my grandmother's apartment at 7:00, I'd still have a couple of quality hours boiling in blissful weightlessness before bedtime.
As Christmas plans continued to take shape, I kept my mother apprised.
So at lunchtime on Christmas Eve, Jim and I arrived at Grandmom's. It was truly wonderful to see her. Because there would be guests, my uncle convinced her to decorate a tree (even though in later years she considered herself too old to "make a mess"), and he dragged out all of her old-fashioned flaking glass ornaments and recycled strands of silver tinsel, neatly repacked into their narrow little boxes, and the strings of colored lights with the big screw-in bulbs. The tree looked exactly the same as it had when I was little. I was so pleased.
Around 3:00, my mother called and spoke to my grandmother.
"Yer mudder says she'll be over as soon as she takes a shower," Grandmom said in her Old Philadelphia accent.
Relatives started showing up, so I nuked the food and spread it out on the kitchen table along with the disposable Santa Claus partyware. The cornflake-encrusted apricot chicken nuggets were a hit, and my peanut butter muffins with chocolate chunks are always to die for. But the carrot dish tasted like puke. Oh, well.
Anyway, what was originally supposed to be a quiet visit with Grandmom turned into a full-blown Christmas Eve shindig, with caroling and gift-giving and the taking of big group photos. No sign of my parents, though.
Eventually, 7:00 was upon us. Looking around, I knew some people had no intention of leaving anytime soon, but I intended to keep my word. Besides, my back had that appointment with a $200-a-night hot tub. And boy, was I ready for that.
But I stayed a little beyond 7:00, because my parents still hadn't shown. I at least wanted to say hello. What was keeping them? My mother called hours ago.
Finally, my brother appeared with his girlfriend, followed soon after by my parents and sister. We chatted a bit, posed for Kodak moments, and then I slipped away to the kitchen to pack away leftovers. On my way out of the room I asked my brother:
"Are you and Patty coming to breakfast tomorrow?"
He looked at me strangely, as though this was the first time he was hearing about it. Then he shrugged and nodded.
Great! We were going to have such a relaxing and festive Christmas morning.
After the food was cleaned up I went to my grandmother's bedroom and dug into the mound of coats on the bed, looking for my own. As I pulled it on, my lower back shrieked.
My mother and sister appeared in the doorway. They looked at me funny.
"Kim? You going to stop over the house?" my mother asked.
Huh?
"What do you mean?" I said. "Tonight?"
She nodded.
"Uh…no. No, Mom. I…I told you, we got that room with the hot tub. At the Inn of the Dove."
Why would she even ASK me that? Stop over? To her place? Tonight? Wait -- the whole point was for me to limit my time at her apartment, because it made. Me. Sick! And she knew I was paying for this damn hot tub. Why would she expect me to suddenly throw all my plans down the john now? It just didn't make any sense.
I could tell something was up. My mother was being quiet and sulky. And my sister, great protector of Mom and Dad, champion child and keeper of the sacred status quo, stood close at her side.
Jim and I departed closer to 8:00 than 7:00. But I still enjoyed about 90 minutes of delicious hot tubbing, and with a glass of wine in-hand and Rudolph on the telly. Mmmmm, ecstacy.
Early the next morning, Jim and I exchanged our gifts on the motel room floor, beneath a tiny little potted pine we'd driven all the way from a corner florist in Manhattan and strung it with little white lights. (I got a complete set of Spinal Tap action figures that morning -- SCORE!)
Then we dressed and went to my parents', ready for our Ritz Diner breakfast, followed by gift-opening under my mother's tree.
She opened her apartment door, still wearing her nightgown.
In a dry, flat, seemingly rehearsed and passive-aggressive voice, she spoke:
"Hi, Kim. How are you."
Notice I typed no question mark after "How are you". That's accurate. How are you. THUD.
O.K. Somebody had a bug up their ass. What was her friggin' problem already, on Christmas morning?
Jim and I shot each other a look and took seats in the room. As we passed the kitchen, I spied dirty dishes in the sink, a skillet encrusted with scrambled egg.
Clearly, they'd already had breakfast.
My sister rushed over and shooed the dog away from me.
"Out of the way, Patches! Go in the kitchen, go! Here, Kim," she said, "sit over here by the window. You'll get some fresh air."
My parents ambled over -- Dad wasn't dressed for breakfast, either. They sat on twin ottomans directly in front of me and promptly lit up cigarettes and started puffing away in my face.
They made an attempt at small talk, asking about the motel. I answered them pleasantly, matter-of-factly. Because in my world, nothing was wrong.
Except for this icy reception, of course. It was agonizing. I couldn't wait for this morning to be over. Present-opening time couldn't come soon enough.
As they unwrapped their home-made robes, my mother temporarily shed her armor and gushed over them. I thought everything, whatever "everything" was, was O.K.
But darkness -- and the attitude -- soon re-settled over the room.
It was clear to me we weren't going out to breakfast. They'd already had breakfast. They'd failed to get dressed. They'd chosen to shun the plan. And they'd chosen not to speak about it. Chosen not to explain why they were pretending we didn't have other arrangements. Chosen not to explain what the hell was eating them.
Jim and I collected our gifts and left. As we said good-bye to my brother and Patty, they looked a little confused. Their faces implored, "But what about breakfast?" But it wasn't for me to explain. I'd let my mother do that.
I realized later that my mother probably never told my brother, or anybody else, about my proposed Christmas agenda. Not breakfast, not my promise to leave Grandmom's at 7:00, not the hot tub, none of it. And I don't know why. She decided to let people think I was some kind of bad guy.
I e-mailed my mother after Christmas and asked for my brother's address so I could send him a thank you card for his gift. Her response was cold. It was just an address -- no greeting, nothing more.
I've heard nothing from my mother since. Nor from my dad, brother, or sister.
That's right -- nothing. In over five years.
I have an uncle who loves to instigate trouble. Uncle Bob. He gossips like an old woman. And a couple of years ago, he called to tell me he'd been at my parents' home and "they were sittin' around the kitchen table talking about how what you did that one Christmas was unforgiveable."
And what had I done, exactly?
I'd drawn up a plan. A reasonable plan that put a cap on my allergy-related misery while still letting my mother have all her children in one place for Christmas. A plan that allowed for 90 meager minutes of relief for my aching back while still allowing for family togetherness on Christmas Eve.
Unforgiveable. How dare I think of myself, for even a minute!
I'm willing to cut my dad and siblings a little slack, because at this very moment, they're probably acting from an uninformed place. From the perspective of someone who didn't know my plans that Christmas, it may have looked like I threw a party at my grandmother's house and then skipped out as soon as my nuclear family arrived. Which, to a paranoid person or someone big into The Blame Game or playing The Victim, could be interpreted as me shunning them. It could've looked like I was turning my nose up at their Christmas Eve invitation. It probably sounded weird when I asked my brother, "Are you coming to breakfast tomorrow?" when he hadn't been clued in to the plan, and then even weirder when Jim and I left the next morning without any further mention of breakfast.
And from what's trickled down the grapevine over the years, it sounds like my actions have been venomously interpreted, and I have been enthusiastically demonized.
My mother made a choice. She chose to hear out my plan, agree with it, coo through the phone that it all sounded wonderful, then make believe our conversations never took place.
I guess my agenda didn't fit in with her idea of the perfect Norman Rockwell Christmas.
If she'd stomped her feet and had a red-faced tantrum like a toddler not getting its way, she would have looked just as foolish as she does now -- but not nearly as heartless.
What I did that Christmas was unforgiveable, they say.
I guess my mother needed a reason to hate her daughter. A reason to alienate her daughter. To tidy things up. To get the trouble-making, truth-telling daughter out of the picture.
So she made up a reason. She cleaned things up reeeeal nice.
Now she's got one daughter left. A daughter who boasts on her MySpace page that her mom and dad are her heroes -- the best parents in the world!!!
And I suppose that's just how my mother always wanted it.
Uncle Bob the Gossip actually made sense when he said of the whole situation, "Your mother has turned her back on her maternal instinct. And that's plain sick."
But like I hinted earlier, this is not such a bad thing. You see, my mother gave me a wonderful gift that Christmas when she shut me out of her life, and enrolled the rest of the family in it. She spared me of a highly contagious family disease. The longer I'm away from them, the healthier and stronger I feel.
I know the illness rages on, because I hear it when members of my extended family call.
Just last weekend my Uncle Russell rang and was talking about his sister, my Aunt Linda. He blamed her for the fact that few people from my grandmother's church came to her funeral.
"Your Aunt Linda's been down at that church bad-mouthing our family to all those people!" he insisted. "She's runnin' us all down!"
He had no hard evidence, mind you. But to him, it sounded good. It sounded likely, and that was true enough.
"Well, you don't know that for sure," I said. "You don't know what she's been saying to people, at Grandmom's church or anywhere else."
"Well, that's true," he admitted, with the briefest glimmer of sanity. "But as far as I'm concerned, she ruined your grandmother's legacy at that church!"
I wondered if he actually realized what he'd just said. As far as he was concerned, fiction was truth, because that's the way he wanted it.
And that's just crazy talk.
Maybe my Aunt Linda does bad-mouth her family at my grandmother's church. But my uncle wasn't there to hear it. He merely imagined the whole thing. He guessed at it.
He obviously needed a new reason to hate his sister. A reason to cast her out. He needed somewhere to put his grief, so he heaped it in a pile of blame, and heaped it on her. And he injected it all with the melodrama that's so typical of my family (and that they ironically always attributed to me, "Sarah Bernhardt"): "She RUINED your grandmother's LEGACY!!!"
My grandmother wasn't Mother Theresa, O.K? She was just a sweet little old lady who loved her church.
But my Aunt Linda ruined my grandmother's legacy! And what I did that Christmas was unforgiveable!
What my family lacks in personal strength, they make up for in bitterness and anger.
What they lack in fact, they make up for by making things up.
And there's not enough humility in all of them put together for any one of them to ever, ever say,
"You know what? I was wrong. I shouldn't have done or said that. I don't know what I was thinking. I'd like to learn how to do better."
Never.
Instead, there will be a lifetime of questions from strangers, "Do you see your mother at Christmas? I never hear you mention your mother."
No, I don't see my mother at Christmas. That was a choice she made several Christmases ago.
Is it sad to know you've been rejected by your mother? And for no good reason?
Of course it is. It's downright heartbreaking.
But being finally rejected is a one-time deal. Somehow, it's more heartbreaking to be an up-close, ongoing witness to complete abandonment of reason and reality in the people you grew up thinking had all the answers. That'll kill you again and again -- if you let it.
Links to recent blogs:
October 20, 2007
September 30, 2007
Day Job Believer – September 12, 2007
Clueless in Philadelphia – September 2, 2007
It's Christmas in August! – August 7, 2007
Whatcha thinkin', Houdini? – July 24, 2007