"I’m In You has a lightly unnerving rock sound with the ability to be minimalist and orchestral all at once."
Alicia Neubauer - CD Insight

"As revolting as the name I'm in You is (it was a Peter Frampton album title, after all), the Brooklyn drama rockers' racket almost makes up for it. This is because of the way they often use a steady, almost-disco drum beat to support non sequitur Afro-beat horns and Zappa-like flourishes. When pinned against their speak-sing vocals and war-centric tongue-in-cheek lyrics, you gotta figure these guys own every Talking Heads, Violent Femmes, and later Camper Van Beethoven record ever released."
Kory Grow - Village Voice

"Brooklyn’s I’m in You augments its funky, grittily urgent postpunk with striking horn arrangements."
-Time Out NY