MySpace


Julian Jaynes & the Origin of Consciousness



Last Updated: 12/23/2009

Send Message
Instant Message
Email to a Friend
Subscribe

Gender: Male
Status: Single
Age: 36
Sign: Pisces

City: Los Angeles, Boston, Austin
State: New York
Country: US
Signup Date: 10/30/2007

Who Gives Kudos:


Monday, February 18, 2008 

Check out a new radio interview on Jaynes's bicameral mind theory:

http://www.astraeamagazine.com/

Click on Radio > 2008 > Marcel Kuijsten

(A section on the auditory hallucinations of the prophet Muhammad was deemed too controversial and was edited out.)

The Meaning Project

 
Having listened to the interview and read most of your blogs, is it safe to assume that Joan of Arc experienced bicameral hallucinations, or is it more likely that she was schizophrenic, as other thinkers like Viktor Frankl have guessed?
 
Posted by The Meaning Project on Wednesday, February 20, 2008 - 7:50 AM
[Reply to this
Julian Jaynes & the Origin of Consciousness

 
The distinction may be a false one. What I mean is that according to Jaynes's theory, all auditory hallucinations are a vestige of the bicameral mind. So people who are diagnosed as schizophrenic today are experiencing a partial relapse to the bicameral mind.

Also, recent studies show far more "normal" people hallucinate than was previously believed, but they keep it to themselves because of the stigma of mental illness.

So today Joan of Arc may have been considered schizophrenic, or she may have functioned relatively normally despite her hallucinations, as many do today. According to Jaynes all auditory hallucinations are a hold over from our previous mentality.
 
Posted by Julian Jaynes & the Origin of Consciousness on Wednesday, February 20, 2008 - 8:05 AM
[Reply to this
Stephen Dufrechou
Stephen Dufrechou

 
Fascinanting, truly. I'm looking forward to reading the books...

Something else that I just thought about... (and I don't know if one can make a connection out of this in any way)... is the assertion by many critics and philosophers that the logic of postmodern philosopy is similar to schizophrenic thought patterns.... any thoughts on that notion?
 
Posted by Stephen Dufrechou on Thursday, February 21, 2008 - 10:12 AM
[Reply to this