Home Page My Times Today's Paper Video Most Popular Times Topics
Movies All NYT
Wednesday, August 13, 2008
MoviesWorld U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos Search Movies, People and Showtimes by ZIP Code
Top-Rated in Theaters
Select a Movie Title WALL-E In Search of a Midnight Ki... Encounters at the End of t... The Dark Knight The Edge of Heaven Kung Fu Panda Gonzo: The Life and Work o... Days and Clouds My Father, My Lord Mongol More Movies... More in Movies »
In Theaters Critics'
Picks On DVD Tickets &
Showtimes Trailers Shopping
CartAdvertise on NYTimes.comMovie Review
Man on Wire (2008)NYT Critics' Pick This movie has been designated a Critic's Pick by the film reviewers of The Times.
Jean-Louis Blondeau/Polaris
Philippe Petit in "Man on Wire."

July 25, 2008
Walking on Air Between the Towers
E-MAIL Print Save Share
LinkedinDiggFacebookMixxYahoo! BuzzPermalink

By A. O. SCOTT
Published: July 25, 2008

On the morning of Aug. 7, 1974, after months of preparation and years of dreaming, a French daredevil named Philippe Petit stepped into the sky above Lower Manhattan. For almost 45 minutes he ambled back and forth on a metal cable strung between the towers of the World Trade Center, a feat of illegal tightrope walking that, according to a New York Police Department sergeant who recounted Mr. Petit's act of physical poetry in dry press-conference prose, would more aptly be described as dancing.


More About This Movie
Overview New York Times Review Cast, Credits & Awards Readers' Reviews (43)Skip to next paragraph
Skip to next paragraph
Multimedia
Exclusive Clip: 'Man on Wire'
Related
Film: High-Wire Act for a Film Festival (April 18, 2008)
For many years after, Mr. Petit's stunt was a cherished footnote in the annals of New York history, one of the touchstones of a crazy, awful, glittering era in the life of the city. The destruction of the twin towers in the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, revived the memory of that earlier aesthetic assault on the buildings, which is now the subject of "Man on Wire," James Marsh's thorough, understated and altogether enthralling documentary. Wisely, Mr. Marsh, who based his film on a book Mr. Petit published in 2002, never alludes to Sept. 11. That would have been both distracting and redundant, since it's impossible, while watching a movie so intimate in its attention to the towers, not to be haunted by thoughts of their fate.



But it is also worth recalling that the trade center inspired more love posthumously than while it stood. Mr. Petit was an exception. A zealous, daring wire walker — the French word funambule is a more lyrical, as well as a somewhat more ridiculous-sounding term — he conceived a passion for the structures even before they were built.



As he recalls it (and as Mr. Marsh imagines the scene in one of many witty, unobtrusive re-enactments), the young Mr. Petit was flipping through a magazine at a doctor's office when he saw an article about plans to construct the two tallest skyscrapers in the world side by side at the bottom of Manhattan. In his mind, and then in a series of sketches and diagrams, he drew a simple line connecting the buildings and imagined himself perched atop it.



What kind of person would think of such a thing? How would he go about accomplishing it? Why? Those are the questions that preoccupy Mr. Marsh, whose earlier films include the semidocumentary "Wisconsin Death Trip" and the fictional feature "The King."



The first question is answered largely by Mr. Petit's own testimony. In his 50s, he is elfin and energetic, a beguiling combination of showboat, idealist and con man. And in his early, outlaw years, before the twin towers walk brought him fame and a measure of legitimacy, he combined an exalted sense of artistic mission with a street criminal's sense of serious mischief.



Accordingly, "Man on Wire" is constructed like a heist movie, in the manner of "Rififi" or the revived "Ocean's Eleven" franchise. Though Mr. Petit was alone on the cable that August morning, his walk in the sky was the result of a conspiracy of true believers and casual adventurers. In his two previous acts of guerrilla funambulism — at the Cathedral of Notre-Dame in Paris and on the Harbor Bridge in Sydney — he relied on the logistical and moral support of several friends, including his lover, Annie Allix, and his faithful sidekick, Jean-Louis Blondeau.



In interviews, they and some of Mr. Petit's other confederates — including two American goofballs and Barry Greenhouse, a flamboyant insurance executive who served as the all-important inside man — reconstruct their project, which they referred to at the time as "the coup," in fascinating detail. There were engineering problems and also challenges that seem to belong to the world of espionage, as well as the inevitable tensions that arise when a group of people pursue a dangerous goal.



Why did they do it? Rather than risking banality by addressing this question head-on, Mr. Marsh allows the answer to be at once self-evident and profoundly mysterious. A work of art is its own explanation, and "Man on Wire" leaves no doubt that Mr. Petit's coup deserves to be called art. Mr. Blondeau, a sensitive and cerebral foil to the impish Mr. Petit, chokes up when he recalls watching his friend step out over the abyss. "The important thing is that we did it," he says.



And without making any grandiose claims, this lovely, touching film demonstrates that the World Trade Center sky walk was an important event. The proof is in the emotions — amusement, amazement, awe — evoked by those images of a tiny human figure balancing above a void. Also gratitude. It is easy to imagine that, in contemplating the scale and solidity of those brand-new towers, Mr. Petit saw them at least partly as the vehicle of his own immortality (whether or not he survived the crossing). No one looking up at the New York sky on a hazy morning 34 years ago and seeing a man on a wire could have suspected that the reverse would turn out to be true.



"Man on Wire" is rated PG-13 (Parents strongly cautioned). It includes nudity, sexuality and drug references.


Average Reader Rating

4½ rating, 228 votesRate It
Log In to Rate This Movie
Readers' Reviews (43)Write a Review
43.August 8th, 2008Rating:
Great historical footage; ok documentary
I'm a little surprised by all of the glowing reviews and have to say I was disappointed after I watched the documentary last night. I agree with A.O. Scott that the decision to refrain from any explicit references to 9/11 was a good one. The sober, elegiac footage/images of the towers, and those of Petit crossing them, are certainly the best aspects of the film. However, the power of those images is substantially weakened by the intermittent hokey reenactments and oft-flippant (and sometimes self-aggrandizing) commentary which dominate the screen. For me, the beauty of the images themselves stands on its own, and everything else merely serves to detract from that beauty. In my opinion, the film's promotional poster, which features a graceful, improbable still of Petit traversing the twin towers, is a bit misleading. A more accurate reflection of the film's predominant content would have perhaps shown a silly, mime-like image of Petit.
- fhixxvmdslac42.August 8th, 2008Rating:
Great historical footage; ok documentary
I'm a little surprised by all of the glowing reviews and have to say I was disappointed after I watched the documentary last night. I agree with A.O. Scott that the decision to refrain from any explicit references to 9/11 was a good one. The sober, elegiac footage/images of the towers, and those of Petit crossing them, are certainly the best aspects of the film. However, the power of those images is substantially weakened by the intermittent hokey reenactments and oft-flippant (and sometimes self-aggrandizing) commentary which dominate the screen. For me, the beauty of the images themselves stands on its own, and everything else merely serves to detract from that beauty. In my opinion, the film's promotional poster, which features a graceful, improbable still of Petit traversing the twin towers, is a bit misleading. A more accurate reflection of the film's predominant content would have perhaps shown a silly, mime-like image of Petit.
- colonelsanders
Read All Readers' Reviews »
Related Articles
CHEERING SECTION; Olympic Moments: What Happens Afterward (August 3, 2008) MOVIE REVIEW | PROFIT MOTIVE AND THE WHISPERING WIND; Holding an All Saints' Day Of American Radicals (August 1, 2008) FILM; Two Amateurs, Reinventing The Wheel (July 27, 2008) MOVIE REVIEW | 'AMERICAN TEEN'; Lives of Real Adolescents, In Very Deep Close-Up (July 25, 2008) Ads by Google what's this?

10 Rules of Flat Stomach:
Cut down 9 lbs of Stomach Fat every 11 Days by Obeying these Ten Rules.
FatLoss4Idiots.com
"How To Lose Belly Fat"
CNN Special Report: Try This Secret Proven to Melt Your Belly Fat.
www.FireYourFat.com
13 Things Defy Science
What are They? Can they be Solved? Who is Trying? Find Out Now.
www.13thingsthatdontmakesense.com

Tickets & Showtimes
Enter your ZIP code or city to view tickets and showtimes in your area.

Advertise on NYTimes.com


nytimes.com/travel


One tank road-trips around the U.S.
Also in Travel:

Adventures in Bolivia Cape Cod, in Edward Hopper's light A weekend away in Denver

Advertisements
HomeWorld U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos Back to Top
Copyright 2008 The New York Times CompanyPrivacy Policy Search Corrections RSS First Look Help Contact Us Work for Us Media Kit Site Map