MySpace
myspace music


Karine Polwart



Last Updated: 11/18/2009

Send Message
Instant Message
Email to a Friend
Subscribe

Status: Married
City: Scottish Borders
State: Scotland
Country: UK
Signup Date: 10/30/2005

Who Gives Kudos:


Wednesday, February 25, 2009 

Shortly after Jenny-The-Orang-utan first arrived at London Zoo in 1837, causing her most eminent possible visitor, Queen Victoria, to exclaim that she was “most painfully and disagreeably human”, Charles Darwin slipped a harmonica, a sprig of verbena and a bag of peppermints into his overcoat and stopped by to see her.  It seems, according to his notebooks, that she liked whatever it was he played on the moothie (and how I wish I knew!) and was quite fussy for both the taste and smell sensations he brought with him.

This scene makes me chuckle. It makes me think of my dad, a man who has been known to lie flat out on a bustling Edinburgh High Street in order to get just the right angle for a photo and who, at one point I seem to recall, had a notion that the undersides of windowsills held secrets for those bold enough, and sufficiently un-embarrassed, to look there.

If you thought Darwin was some kind of cool, emotionally distant scientist, think again. Having immersed myself in books by and about him, radio and TV documentaries (and isn’t David Attenborough just a total dude?), as well embarking on an Open University course in Evolution (heck, why not eh?) what’s as striking as the importance of the ideas Darwin cultivated and those developed since, is his humanity, empathy, tenderness, humour and decency. Irrelevant, you might say, to the subject of science? But not so, it seems to me.

A man who didn’t play with his (many) children could not have made parallels between the emotions and behaviour of apes and other animals and human beings, at a time when humans were considered a separate and higher order of life.  Nor would a cultural snob have found his way into the rank London slums of his day to question pigeon fanciers about their selective breeding methods (and so fallen for the art and the creatures themselves that he bred around a thousand birds himself subsequently with his daughter Etty). And a man with a less acute sense of fun might have found other ways to test the hearing capacity of earthworms than by asking his son Frank to play them bassoon solos. They don’t, incidentally, hear at all.

But, most poignant of all, his theories about the centrality of death, extinction and the struggle for survival to the evolution of life, based as they were on his own experiments in his home and garden, his tropical travels on The Beagle and a mountain of careful correspondence with botanists, geologists, dog breeders, farmers, sailors and adventurers (some 15,000 letters remain) acquired a harrowing personal significance with the illness and eventual death of his beloved eldest daughter Annie at the age of 10.

My admiration and affection for the man is growing by the day. And for someone who hasn’t studied biology since she was thirteen I’m really enjoying (and beginning to understand) the science too. So I feel I’m doing my own wee bit to prepare for a week-long writers residency in celebration of the 200th anniversary of Darwin’s birth (I doubt if it has passed you by), organised by Shrewsbury Folk Festival, and due to start in three weeks time. I’ll be holed up in a house outside the city where Darwin was born with, amongst others, Chris Wood, Emily Smith, Jez Lowe and US singer-songwriter Krista Detor. The residential project culminates in a gig at Theatre Severn in Shrewsbury on Thursday 19th March. Maybe see a few of you there for some brand new just-out-of-the-bag songs.

And maybe, just maybe, one inspired by the curious fact that Darwin was born on exactly the same day as that icon of American history Abraham Lincoln. “The Ballad of Chuck and Abe” anyone?




Bill Dodds
Bill Dodds

 
I was talking to a lady in Sainsbury's car park; wife of a friend. She studying something like the evangelism in Ulster Protestantism at a similar time to Darwin; hoping to look at Birmingham and Liverpool next. Striking that as Darwin and Marx are pushing God to one side, she finds there is an upsurge in evangelical activity in great cities amongst both Catholic and Protestant.


Is Darwin evangelical in his discoveries?

Fascinating blog; Thanks


 
Posted by Bill Dodds on Wednesday, February 25, 2009 - 10:21 AM
[Reply to this
Phil
Philip Lord

 
Not sure whether he was evangelical or not, Bill. He certainly was a seeker of truth.

Greal blog, Karine, that I think I will reread and ponder......
 
Posted by Phil on Wednesday, February 25, 2009 - 8:51 PM
[Reply to this
Andy J

 
Excellent to hear that you are enjoying your Darwin explorations Karine - he certainly was a fascinating man. I'm looking forward to the Shrewsbury concert and your Clonter Opera gig too - this is a new venue for us although close to home! Cheers, Andy.

 
Posted by Andy J on Wednesday, February 25, 2009 - 1:37 PM
[Reply to this
Ally Cochrane

 
I'm facinated by this idea of the Darwin song house... given that On The Origin Of Species was published nearly 150 years ago are there existing old songs that touch upon the subject?
 
Posted by Ally Cochrane on Wednesday, February 25, 2009 - 2:31 PM
[Reply to this
ROY HENDERSON

 
Great blog. Been considering Mr Darwin too of late.

And yes, Mr Attenborough is indeed THE dude.
Who's going to take over the baton when he finally retires?
And I think you should write that ballad now before someone comes along and steals your thunder!
 
Posted by ROY HENDERSON on Saturday, February 28, 2009 - 5:39 PM
[Reply to this
Dave
Dave Horne

 

Fascinating to read your thoughts about Darwin and evolution. In April this year, just two days after the anniversary of Annie’s death, I was privileged to organise a scientific meeting (doing my bit for Darwin Year) in a room on the top floor of Down House, Darwin’s former residence; I opened the proceedings by thanking Mrs Darwin for the use of her bedroom.  Being an amateur singer as well as a professional scientist I (like Ally Cochrane) have been looking for relevant songs; since last Wednesday when I heard “We’re all leaving” on Mike Harding’s programme I can stop looking - thank you, it’s perfect, and well worth the wait.  
Dave Horne


 
Posted by Dave on Saturday, August 15, 2009 - 2:28 PM
[Reply to this