The art debate.

So I got into a heated debate, an argument, a discussion, a flat-out skirmish about "art" and what's unique.

On one side we have Mr. M < --- not his real name, obviously, who's a firm believer and appreciator of renaissance era artwork, AKA Realism. He states that this the greatest art form, outshining all other art forms, abstract, modern, etc…..and 'anime-style' stuff.  He claims that this is the most unique. Realism is about proportions, etc., and the way he talks about it, it's more about the calculations rather than the actual art.

I am more of an anime-is style artist. More of a Tim Burton inspired Anime with a touch of fashion designer thrown in. I believe in unique-ness and individuality when it comes to art. So what if the proportions aren't exact, and so what if the shading isn't precise.

Art isn't supposed to be about "Calculations", it's supposed to be about creativity, self expression. He essentially stated, not in words, but this is the impression I got, that my art isn't unique, that another can reproduce it, and it's essentially crap compared to, say The Creation of Adam  ( a piece of art done by Leonardo Da Vinci)

I am not saying I don't appreciate "realistic" art, I do. I can understand the effort that goes into it, and the skill, but saying it "outshines" the other work?

Not exactly. I don't think so. I can look at a Tim Burton creation, say like the Corpse Bride movie, and go wow, that's fucking brilliant, and immensely beautiful. -.-   and then look at a  painting from the 1660's, and go ..Wow…That's mastery.

There are many forms of art, and they should all be recognized as something great. No matter if you don't like the subject manner.

I don't have skill at doing realism, so I am not an artist? Really, you don't say?! That's rude. I don't attempt to be "unique", I just am. I am sorry if I draw anime-ish style and every teenager happens to be like that.

Most bring a different angle to it.

Furthermore, This "Mr. M", doesn't even draw most of the time.  Which, essentially, means he's not an artist and what does a kid who doesn't even draw even have the right to criticize something? One shouldn't sit there and talk as if they know something when they can't even do it.