MySpace


MJ



Last Updated: 5/21/2007

Send Message
Instant Message
Email to a Friend
Subscribe

Gender: Female
Status: Married
Age: 46
Sign: Leo

City: INDIANAPOLIS
State: INDIANA
Country: US
Signup Date: 6/29/2006

Who Gives Kudos:


Tuesday, November 21, 2006 

Category: News and Politics
Boy, was my face red. It's embarrassing, on a personal level, to recommend a business to your publisher, and then have them refuse to work with him.

Ken at Seventh Window wanted to print up some bookmarks for Discreet Young Gentleman, and because I spend allllll of my time online, I looked around and found what looked like a decent deal: My1Stop.com. Except, when Ken submitted the order, it was refused. The email, which came from customer service representative Greg Schroeder, referred to this policy:

You further agree that My1Stop™ will not be used by you to post, email, upload, transmit, distribute or otherwise make available any materials or content that is unlawful, harmful, threatening, harassing, abusive, obscene, tortuous, defamatory, vulgar, pornographic, libelous, invasive of another's privacy, hateful, racially, ethnically, sexually or otherwise objectionable.  My1Stop™ reserves the right to reject, remove, delete or modify any content submitted by you.


Greg did not, however, indicate which part of the policy DYG's cover was considered to be violating. So, embarrassed that Ken had taken my advice and gotten his hand slapped, I called Greg up to ask what the heck happened. Greg said while it was his province to send out the emails, he had not made the decision--that came from someone above him. For clarification, I asked if he thus didn't know which part of the policy was violated, and he confirmed that he did not. He told me his supervisor, Shana, would know, but that he believed she was in a meeting. Would I like her voice mail?

No, I'd rather have her extension. Greg gave it to me, and just on the off chance, I gave Shana a call right away. She was in the office, and spoke to me, identifying herself as Shana Emerson, Office Manager. Again, she referred me to the policy, saying at first that the company made the decisions. When pressed, however, for the actual name of the person who reviewed the artwork, she said she was the one who refused to print the order.

Okay, why? Well, she would have to review the artwork again. No problem--did she have a computer in front of her? Yes? Then try DiscreetYoungGentleman.com. Oh, that would surely be blocked. How about marlyspearson.com? I spelled it for her, she brought up the page, and put me on hold. After a few minutes she came back. Was I still there? Oh, yes. Okay: she had judged the graphic sexual in nature. As a Christian-based company, they were not going to print anything sexual in nature. Did she mean homosexual in nature?

No, absolutely not. It was the lack of shirts. So this is My1Stop's policy, in a nutshell, from Shana Emerson: they will indeed print projects containing gay content, as long as the people in the graphic are wearing shirts. They will not print heterosexual projects, such as Fabio-type romance covers, if the male model is not wearing a shirt. Indeed, she told me that they had refused to print a Fabio-cover project.

Nice to have that cleared up.

By the way, we're going with PrintingForLess.com. Turns out their prices are better, anyway.
Previous Post: Update | Back to Blog List | Next Post: Music that makes me sweat
Michael

 

Well I certainly hope she was not lying through her teeth about the gay content not being a problem, however.....

Glad you found a better deal

 


 
Posted by Michael on Tuesday, November 21, 2006 - 3:28 PM
[Reply to this
MJ

 
It certainly would be interesting to test...

But even if she's completely serious, I think the company is shooting itself in the foot by refusing to work with the "shirtless hunk" category of romance covers. Not only is romance an incredibly lucrative market to alienate (the RWA reports that 39.3 % of all fiction sales are romance, a figure that jumps up to 55% of mass market fiction), but the romance genre, with its defined happy-ending requirement, is the last bastion of fiction where sexual activity is pretty much guaranteed to be either the result of, or leading up to a monogamous, committed relationship.

Unlike, for instance, horror or thrillers, where sex can be as nasty and anonymous as you like...but hey, as long as your serial killer is wearing a shirt on the cover, presumably that's cool with My1Stop.

 
Posted by MJ on Tuesday, November 21, 2006 - 6:07 PM
[Reply to this
NL Gassert

 

OUCH.

 

Good for you, MJ, for getting that woman on the phone and pressing her for an answer. I think I would have been too embarrassed to come out of my dark hole yet.

 

Christian-based, huh? I’m guessing they probably wouldn’t print any horror covers with vampires or depictions of pentagrams. That would likely fall under “otherwise objectionable.” Tsk.


 
Posted by NL Gassert on Tuesday, November 21, 2006 - 6:41 PM
[Reply to this
MJ

 
Hey, NL, I used to be a hole-dweller myself, but after becoming an author of gay romance I, uh, came out. "Otherwise objectionable" conveniently covers a lot of ground, doesn't it? I sensed a good deal of reluctance to be pinned down to specifics, and Shana certainly didn't want me to blog about this (about that spelling thing, Shana? I Googled you)--which brings up the question Why? Don't they want their policies to be known, so that they only get the business they find acceptable?

It would even help if they identified themselves on their website as a Christian-based company--I just looked around, and can't see so much as a little fish anywhere. Not that I have any problem with Christian businesses, but (contrary to the belief of some) I don't go looking for fights, and I'd have been forewarned that they might not want to deal with us if I'd known.

 
Posted by MJ on Tuesday, November 21, 2006 - 7:06 PM
[Reply to this
Previous Post: Update | Back to Blog List | Next Post: Music that makes me sweat