MySpace

"The Trash-Heap has spoken! Nyaaa!" (please tell me some of you remember that!)

Friday, April 18, 2008 3:19 AM

Category: Religion and Philosophy
Okay, the discussion in the previous post was FREAKIN' AWESOME!  (Thanks to all of you who responded). 

However, it also became FREAKIN' LONG!  (Again, thanks to all of you who responded!)

So rather than keep responding on that post, I thought I'd move this part of the discussion into a new post altogether.

For those of you who need a recap, you can read the original post here to catch you up to speed.

I feel like the discussion turned a corner begining with my man Dave Hickman's response which I'll pick up with and include my responses.  Here goes:

David's response to the Christian Party Girl phenomenon and it's root causes:
1 - Over compensation for thier attempt to not be portrayed as a legalistic, bible-thumping, ultra-conservative females.
2 - Single but not stale. I think most single ladies wants guys (who might check out thier page) to know that they are Christian, but not Mother Teresa. Again, you have to take into account that gals know guys wil check out thier page. So, what do they want them to know about them? "I love Jesus, but I'm not a stick-in-the-mud." I think there is a fear that if thier profile is all Jesus stuff, it will freak them out. If it is all booty, beer-drinking pics, it will turn them off (or on in the wrong way.) I think they try to meet in the middle and it ends up confusing everyone.
3 - Acceptance. Jenni K said it...not me. But let's go deeper than acceptance. How about fear? The fear of NOT being accpeted will lead folks to portray themselves how they think others want to view them. Do that for too long...you end up not being anybody but a sterotype. Be yourself.
  4 - Being "tagged" with photos. Someone might tag them with a photo that they do not want on thier page. Do you (a) erase it and be a hypocrite? Or, (b) leave it and own it? Tough choice. If choose (b) more photos always come.
5 - It just fun to go out with friends. Friends take pictures. Pictures get on the web.
6 - It's fun to go out to fun places. Fun for one person might be going to the library. Fun for someone else might be going out to Cosmos on Friday night for sushi and half off wine (and a cigar).
NOTE - Not promoting relative ethics above. We are all wired differently and have fun in different ways that are not exactly sinful.
Be smart. Think about who is viewing your profile. Respect God and yourself and you'll be fine.
Word.


JM's response:
Word indeed! Thanks man.

As Christian leaders, what do you think is a good way for us to teach on issues that are clearly labeled as sinful in Scripture, but are misunderstood or not realized by our generation such as revelry, licentiousness, debauchery, etc.? These are such archaic terms, but I've yet to hear of a way to describe them that is clear and understandable to the average Christian 20-30something. As a Discipleship Pastor, I definitely have a heart to see Christians empowered and growing in their faith. It just seems like this is an area where, as you point out, the reaction against "Bible-thumping legalism" often leads to thoughtless libertinism. It's the middle ground that Jesus occupies, I believe.

See you tomorrow night,
JMS

David's response (via CharlotteONE's profile):
Ahh...thus we are getting close to the answer O Great ONE....

Yes, life and freedom (or growing in ones faith) is not found in leagalism (or following a bunch of constricting, anti-social rules) nor is it found in thoughless libertinism or what many call a "license to sin."

There is a third road less traveled, which many Christians have NO CLUE about nor how to walk in it...(including me...allthough I'm learning by God's Grace...)

It's called, "Life by the Spirit."

Paul actually points out this middle ground in Galatians and other epistles, Jesus just lived it out (or wrapped flesh around this truth).

It's a hard answer, I know. Almost sound cliche. But it is not. It's also not what most folks want to hear. It's Certainly not in line with our easy 10 step answers on how to live the Christian life and not be a hypocrite.

Galatians 5 (the whole chapter outlines this concept).

After stating that we are REALLY free from legalistic rules and regulations associated with "The Law," and not supposed to use our freedom to "indulge the sinful nature," Paul says:

v. 16 - So I say, live by the Spirit and you will not gratify in the desires of the sinful nature.

He then rattles off a list of what our sinful nature craves (sexual immoratily, impurity, debauchery, etc)

It's this "living by the Spirit" that we must do to honor God and at the same time be used of him in the lives on non-belieivers.

Sometimes Jesus drank wine (although accepted in his culture)...sometimes he didn't. Sometimes he was filled with righteous anger and turned over tables, sometimes he witheld his frustration in public. Did he have a list of "when to get angry" and when to not in his pocket?

For us "truth" lovers who want an "objective standard" by which to govern our actions, Paul simply says, "Live by the Spirit."

Living life by the direction and submission of the Holy Spirit will guide the beleiver onto and through the middle road.

Man...my wife just summonded me to dinner...

I'll continue this...I'm not done.

Actually...why don't you take over...and I'll pick up where you left off.

Word.

JM's (probably way too long) response:
I'm totally feeling it man. I couldn't agree more.


I was raised a Christian--a Preacher's kid Christian!--and I didn't ever really grasp "walking in the Spirit" until my senior year of college. For me it began with three major sections of Scripture:

1. The book of 1 John, which goes out of its way to emphasize that Christians are characterized by 2 things: Love for God and each other, and a life free from Sin (a very controversial claim in modern Protestant Evangelicalism, though early Wesleyans and even earlier Medieval mystics spent a good deal of time promoting this Biblical truth).

2. Galatians, specifically as you've pointed out in its teaching on living by the Spirit, not by Torah (though ironically fulfilling Torah when one truly lives by the Spirit).

and

3. Romans 5-8, which shows the radical break between our old self, which was imprisoned by Sin, and our new self which is ruled by Christ (a truth many since Luther have missed because of their reading ch.7 as describing Paul's ongoing life as a believer instead of following the rhetorical flow begun in ch.5 and realizing Paul is speaking in the rhetorical 1st person of Adam).

Taking these passages together, I realized exactly what you said above; the Christian life is not a life about obeying rules.

However...

The Christian life is not about tolerating Sin in our lives or settling for anything less than utter Holiness.

These are, I would argue, two sides of the same coin, the coin of "Grace". Grace is freedom from legalism as well as the empowering by the Spirit to live in victory over Sin.

It was when I realized this--really realized it!--that my entire view of the Christian life was turned literally upside down. (Fall of '98 for those of you who knew me then.) It was the first time that I had a genuine desire to not sin based on nothing more than a stronger love for God. It was as if I finally saw Sin--all sin, not just the "big ones"--for what it really is, and wanted absolutely nothing to do with it, be it lust, anger, drunkenness, etc.

The irony is that the biggest hindrance to me seeing all this was actually one of the main reasons I was so strong a believer--my experience growing up in Christian youth groups in church! I had NEVER been taught anything about walking in the Spirit--I had only been taught either "follow these rules and christian subcultural behaviors" or "you'll always be a sinner, that's what grace is for." Legalism or "cheap grace" (as Bonhoeffer would call it).

Incidentally, aside from the Scriptures above, the other biggest "aha" moments came through reading Watchman Nee's magnum opus, "The Spiritual Man"--specifically the first of the three main sections. While I have come to see the errors in some of what Nee taught (most based on exegetical mistakes), this book still holds a place of prominence in my library as far as Spiritual resources goes.

Anyway, this has turned into almost an entire follow-up post! I'd better call it a night.

Maybe I'll post it as a whole new blog entry...

JMS
-----------------------------------------------------------------

And thus we arrive at this post!

Keep the feedback coming,
JMS
jonathan grubbs
Jonathan Grubbs

 
I think the main point you guys are tapping on is this:

The more you walk/crawl in relationship/communion with God, the more you live as you truly should. This leads you to make good decisions, not because you have to, but because you want to. The key is living for God first and not your own dang self.

I admit that I'm drawn to a girl with "party" sensibilities, but a girl that I'd want to marry would have "God" sensibilities.
 
Posted by jonathan grubbs on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 3:10 AM
[Reply to this
James-Michael Smith - Methodist Examiner
James-Michael Smith

 
Ahhh...now this is a good answer...and one that's gonna draw some ire from some of the ladies on here, I bet! It seems to validate the "guys are only attracted to party girls, so that's why we do it in the first place" kinda responses that were posted on the previous entry. I know you well enough to know that's not what you're trying to say. But I can just see it being taken that way.

Thoughts, ladies?
 
Posted by James-Michael Smith - Methodist Examiner on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 3:16 AM
[Reply to this
Mama Dawn

 
What a can of worms indeed. We are faced with two critical issues here. Living by the Spirit or Walking in the Spirit and how to portray ourselves in the public realm. Let’s go with “walking in the Spirit”; that is a true road, a straight path, not a winding one with curves and detours. Not one that we can conveniently detour from for the sake of what we consider “small sin”.

Life in the public realm… our Christian Party Girl is probably making decisions of how to do this based on the anticipated response. They want to attract the opposite sex while desperately trying to preserve their faith. What a balancing act they face. The question is can you walk that straight path in the Spirit when you are off balance?

This issue is like todays society view and love of wealth and money which the Bible had plenty to say about. ”No one can serve two masters. Either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to one and despise the other. You cannot serve both God and money” (Matthew 6:24, NIV). My point in this is that you just can’t have it both ways.
 
Posted by Mama Dawn on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 1:10 PM
[Reply to this
Rachel

 
Hey guys -

I keep thinking of 1 Cor 6:12 throughout this discussion and I'm not sure if anyone has brought it up, but I think it makes a good point.

12 Everything is permissible for me— but not everything is beneficial. Everything is permissible for me— but I will not be mastered by anything.
13 Food for the stomach and the stomach for food— but God will destroy them both. The body is not meant for sexual immorality, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body.

I love the part that says everything is permissible for me - but I will not be mastered by anything - the key being not being mastered by our wrongful desires.

I guess I'm also intrigued by the concept of people, even leaders of younger people, trying to cover up the pictures of them drinking. Are they not teaching that drinking in a public place over the drinking age and drinking in no way to excess in an acceptable manner to Christ is alright? If so, why hide that? Its a pretty easy rule, don't do at any time anything you don't want appearing on your MySpace/Facebook. Or, before acting, imagine would I want Jesus to be beside me if this shows up as a picture on Facebook?

I don't think it is coming down to what is acceptable or not, I think what it seems to be coming down to in the post is the "Oh my Gosh, what will people think if they see me in the picture with a beer in my hand?" If you are right with God and follow his written word, he will rule your heart correctly. So when it comes to picture time, I will take the judgement. And yes, that is a glass of wine in my hand at a large gathering on my Facebook.
 
Posted by Rachel on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 4:08 PM
[Reply to this
James-Michael Smith - Methodist Examiner
James-Michael Smith

 
Good thoughts, Rachel.

I do want to make two points to clarify:

1. The original discussion wasn't aimed at someone having a drink in a picture, or even being with a bunch of friends acting crazy. It was more aimed at the "Oh my gosh I was so hammered, hahah" type attitude that shows up in comments or picture quotes as well as the over-the-top "Girls-Gone-Wild" type of pictures ("Let's act like we're making out with each other", "let's do body shots while double-fisting two vodka bottles for the camera", etc.). That's a bit different than a picture of someone having fun with a drink and friends. And it's that type of thing that I originally wanted to call attention to because, honestly, I think many of the girls who do it genuinely don't realize that there may be elements of sin involved (heck, most people don't even know what "licenstiousness" or "debauchery" mean, much less that they're spoken against in Scripture). [And to note once again...guys are every bit as guilty of this many times as women, they just aren't as visible about combining it with proclamations of Jesus on their profiles.]

2. On a more technical subject, the phrase"everything is permissible for me" in 1Cor. 6:12, along with "Food for stomach and the stomach for food--yet God will destroy them both", are both slogans that the believers in Corinth had adopted in order to justify their extremely libertinism regarding issues of food, sex, and paganism (three things that in Corinth were almost inseperable!). This is why many newer translations put those phrases in quotes. It lets the reader know that Paul wasn't saying them, rather, he was refuting them.

I do like your point about teaching that moderate drinking over the legal age is not wrong and that instead of "hiding" it for fear someone might think bad of us, we should do a better job in teaching about it in the first place. It's interesting to hear the thoughts of British or other European Christians when they hear about the cultural taboo in America that Christians have adapted.

Thanks for adding to the discussion!

JMS
 
Posted by James-Michael Smith - Methodist Examiner on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 5:57 PM
[Reply to this
The Questian
Jermaine Walker

 
This blog has is going to make me late for a job interview. Thanks, JM!
 
Posted by The Questian on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 6:33 PM
[Reply to this
The Questian
Jermaine Walker

 
Correction. This blog IS going to make me late for a job interview. And now it has.
 
Posted by The Questian on Friday, April 18, 2008 - 6:33 PM
[Reply to this
Mama Dawn

 
thought I would see more replies since first was so successful. Didn't see any comment on my reply, maybe I am too cut and dry. Only reason for this additional post is to let our Bible Nerd... my hero, know I remember the Trash Heap LOL. I sure hope I didn't offend anyone... as my first post said, I am not here to Judge... just to offer my insight. Rock on Peeps... Word as you 20's and 30's say. Geez I am not that old... lol. Take care all, and so glad to hear all your repsonses to JMS's post.
 
Posted by Mama Dawn on Saturday, April 19, 2008 - 11:20 PM
[Reply to this
James-Michael Smith - Methodist Examiner

James-Michael Smith


Last Updated: 11/17/2009

Send Message
Instant Message
Email to a Friend
Subscribe

Gender: Male
Status: Single
Age: 31
Sign: Cancer

City: CHARLOTTE
State: NORTH CAROLINA
Country: US
Signup Date: 12/22/2005

Who Gives Kudos: